• Who We Are
    • Who We Are
    • Mission
    • History
    • General Synod
    • Leadership and Ministry
    • Staff
    • United Church of Christ Board
  • What We Believe
    • What We Believe
    • Worship Ways
    • Daily Devotional
  • What We Do
    • What We Do
    • Office of the General Minister & President
    • Justice & Local Church Ministries
    • Wider Church Ministries
  • News
  • Church Finder
  • Donate Now
  • Search
UCC Logo United Church of Christ
  • Church Finder
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Store
  • Frontline Faith Portal
  • Donate Now
  • Search
  • Who We Are
    • Column
      • About
        • Mission
        • Constitution and Bylaws
        • History
          • UCC Archives
        • UCC Brand Guidelines
        • General Synod
          • Synod 33 Worship Videos
          • Past General Synods
        • Abuse Prevention
    • Column
      • Structure
        • Conferences
        • Affiliated Ministries
          • The Pension Boards
          • Cornerstone Fund
          • Insurance Board
          • The Council for Health and Human Services Ministries
          • Church Building & Loan Fund
          • Convergence
    • Column
      • Team
        • Elected Officers
        • Staff
        • United Church of Christ Board
          • Board Minutes
        • Office of General Counsel
        • UCCOSSN
    • Column
      • Career Opportunities
      • Annual Reports
  • What We Believe
    • Column
      • Worship
        • Statement of Faith of the United Church of Christ – La Declaración de Fe de la Iglesia Unida de Cristo
        • Worship Ways
        • Daily Devotional
        • Sermon Seeds
  • How We Serve
    • Column
      • Office of the General Minister & President
        • Welcome to Human Resources
          • Employee Relations Resources
        • Center for Analytics, Research & Development and Data (CARDD)
          • General CARDD FAQs
          • About The Center for Analytics, Research & Development, and Data (CARDD)
          • Authorized Minister Opt Out
          • Access UCC
          • Archived Reports
          • Assessment Resources
          • Information Policies and Requests
          • Faith Communities Today (FACT) Survey
          • MissionInsite
          • Statistics and Reports
          • Vital Signs and Statistics Blog
          • Data Hub FAQs
          • Data Hub
          • Yearbook and Directory
    • Column
      • Justice & Local Church Ministries
        • Justice
          • Faithful Action Ministries
            • Environmental Justice Ministries
            • Economic Justice
            • Racial Justice
          • Office of Public Policy & Advocacy in Washington D.C.
            • Justice and Peace Action Network
            • Our Faith Our Vote
            • Justice Training Resources
            • Action Center
          • Health and Wholeness Advocacy
            • Disabilities and Mental Health Justice
            • Encuentros Latinx
            • UCC HIV & AIDS Network-UCAN
            • LGBTQ Ministries
            • Our Whole Lives
            • Overdose and Drug Use Ministries
            • Scouting
            • Wellness Ministries
          • The Pilgrim Press & Stillspeaking Publications
    • Column
      • Justice & Local Church Ministries
        • Local Church
          • The Faith Education, Innovation and Formation (Faith INFO)Team
            • Weekly Seeds
            • Youth & Young Adults
          • Worship Resources
            • Worship Ways
            • Sermon Seeds
            • Synod 33 Worship Videos
            • Music and Liturgical Arts
          • Stewardship & Generosity Resources
          • Ministerial Excellence, Support & Authorization (MESA)
            • History, Polity, and Theology
            • Search and Call
            • Ministerial Profiles
            • Ministry Opportunities
            • Manual on Ministry
    • Column
      • Wider Church Ministries
        • Global Ministries
        • Global H.O.P.E.
          • Volunteer Ministries
          • Refugee and Migration Ministries
          • Disaster Ministries
          • Recovering Hope
        • Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations
  • Resources
  • News
    • Column
      • News
        • United Church of Christ News
    • Column
      • Columns
        • Witness for Justice
        • Into the Mystic
        • Getting to the Root of It
        • The Pollinator: UCC Environmental Justice Blog
        • UCC Roots
        • Encounters at the Well
        • Reflexiones
    • Column
      • Upcoming Events
        • Webinars
      • Subscriptions at the United Church of Christ
      • Changes & Deaths
  • Giving
    • Column
      • Donate Now
      • Ways to Give
        • Giving Tuesday
        • General Synod 2021 Thursday in Black Offering
        • General Synod 2021 Racial Justice Offering
        • Disaster Ministries: How to Give
        • Our Church’s Wider Mission
          • Our Church’s Wider Mission Basic Support
          • Strengthen the Church
          • One Great Hour of Sharing
          • Neighbors in Need
          • Christmas Fund
          • 5 for 5
    • Column
      • Ways We Give
        • Scholarships & Grants

  • Home
  • News
  • Column
  • Daily COVID-19 briefing from UCC - facts, not fear
  • COVID reopening guidelines: strengths, gaps

COVID reopening guidelines: strengths, gaps

by Barbara T. Baylor | published on Apr 29, 2020

United Church of Christ – Wider Church Ministries
Humanitarian Development Team
Coronavirus (COVID-19) Daily Briefing
Barbara T. Baylor, MPH – Temporary Health Liaison

Strengths, weaknesses of new federal guidelines on “reopening”

Last Thursday, the U.S. government issued new guidelines on “Opening Up America Again.” I think they are a good start – with some gaps and caveats, chiefly that they won’t do any good if we don’t follow them!

Here is a brief recap of the criteria to be satisfied before proceeding to phased reopening.

“Gating” Criteria:

  • Downward trajectory (incidence) of influenza-like illnesses AND “covid-like syndromic cases” reported within a 14-day period.
  • Downward trajectory of documented cases within a 14-day period or downward trajectory of positive tests as a percent of total tests within a 14-day period.
  • Hospitals must treat all patients without crisis care.
  • Robust testing program (is) in place for at-risk healthcare workers, including emerging antibody testing.

Core State Preparedness Criteria:

  • Ability to quickly set up safe and efficient screening and testing sites for symptomatic individuals with contact tracing.
  • Ensure surveillance sites (at locations that serve “older adults, lower-income Americans, racial minorities and Native Americans”) are screening for asymptomatic cases with testing and contact tracing and testing.

Healthcare System Capacity Criteria:

  • Ability to quickly and independently supply sufficient Personal Protective Equipment and critical medical equipment to handle dramatic surge in need.
  • Ability to surge ICU capacity.

Plans:

  • To protect the health and safety of workers in critical issues, of those living and working in high-risk facilities, and employees and users of mass transit.
  • To advise citizens regarding protocols for social distancing and face coverings.
  • To monitor conditions and immediately take steps to limit and mitigate any rebounds or outbreaks by restarting a phase or returning to an earlier phase depending on severity.

According to the new federal guidelines, the above criteria should be met before proceeding with Phase I (and then II and III) of reopening.

An article in The New York Times explores some positives and challenges of the new guidelines:

Positives:

  • It’s a three-phase approach recognizing that reopening is going to be a gradual process. The phases are tied not to strict dates but to metrics.
  • Emergency precautions will be scaled according to the intensity of the problem within a given state or region.
  • It recognizes that not all businesses and facilities pose equal risks of spreading the coronavirus.
  • It emphasizes vulnerable populations and senior living facilities. These facilities will remain at a high risk of explosive growth in cases until we can achieve widespread testing, vaccination and immunity.

Challenges (I would say, “Weaknesses”):

  • Testing continues to be a challenge for many states. It is a key metric for determining safe reopening of the country. There is no requirement that states first show that they have tested enough people to establish that the trajectories they are seeing are truly reflective of population-level trends.
  • Testing guidelines for many states still focus on testing symptomatic people. To stop the spread of the virus the focus must broaden to asymptomatic coronavirus-infected people who can be unwitting super-spreaders.
  • Hospitals are only required to test “at-risk healthcare workers” instead of all health care workers who may be potential sources of risk for spreading the virus.
  • States are tasked with “independently” securing personal protective equipment and key equipment such as ventilators, etc. despite the woefully inadequate assistance from the federal government in the supply chain.
  • No guidance is given as to how states should “pull back” if a resurgence of cases returns. How will states know when to do this?

Some of the hardest hit states and cities including New York, Massachusetts, New Jersey, California, Pennsylvania, Louisiana (New Orleans), Michigan (Detroit) and Illinois (Chicago) continue struggling to control COVID-19 and are cautiously watching for signs that new infections are decreasing.

Some governors have been forming pacts highlighting the importance of using science and advice from health officials rather than politics to choose when to reopen the economy.

But still other governors have already reopened or have set reopen dates in the coming weeks (including Georgia, Ohio, Tennessee, South Carolina), arguably without fulfilling the prerequisites outlined above for a safe phased reopening.

The Director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), Dr. Robert Redfield warned in an interview with the Washington Post on Tuesday that a “potentially worse second wave of coronavirus later this year could … coincide with flu season, which could set up a dangerous double whammy for the health care system.”

Might the “rush to reopen America” contribute to that second wave?

Surveys, including a new one released by the Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, find a clear majority of Americans are wary of “reopening” without protection of their health.

I live in Georgia – a state that already has begun to “reopen.” Am I being assured the protections I need? How much risk am I willing to take when guidelines based on science are being ignored and politics and a few protesters are driving the re-openings?

How about you? 

References:

Guidelines: Opening Up America Again

Nation’s hot spots see rise in COVID-19 deaths

This is where all 50 states stand on reopening

Tracking Covid-19 cases in the U.S.

COVID-19 Daily Briefing Archives

Categories: Column Daily COVID-19 briefing from UCC - facts, not fear

Get the UCC in your inbox!

Sign up for the weekly UCC News Digest

Privacy Policy
 
 

Related News

The Pollinator: UCC Environmental Justice Blog

Land Acknowledgments and Churches

In recent years, it has become increasingly popular to begin public events and worship...

Read More
Into the Mystic

Kindland

Listen to the...

Read More
Witness for Justice
Witness for Justice

Climate Hope

Earlier this week, a couple of related items in my social media feed serendipitously arrived...

Read More
  • Column
    • Local Church and Conference Resource Directory
    • Mission
    • Justice & Local Church Ministries
    • General Synod Resolutions
  • Column
    • Contact
    • News
    • Store

Content on ucc.org is copyrighted by the National Setting of the United Church of Christ and may be only shared according to the guidelines outlined here.

1300 E. 9th Street, Suite 1100
Cleveland, Ohio 44114

  • Follow us on Facebook
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Follow us on Instagram
  • Subscribe on YouTube

Donate Now


UCC Crest
© United Church of Christ 2023. Privacy Policy.
Crafted by Cornershop Creative