Daily Devotional for Small Group Discussions: Too Much and Too Little

Discussion Questions:

  1. How do you practice sharing your questions about faith and seeking out others’ diverse perspectives on similar questions? How does your church practice this exploration of question?

  2. On this Martin Luther King Jr. holiday, how do you ask questions about and listen for others’ experiences of racism? How do you practice “dig[ging] in deep to the things that really matter” in the ongoing work of anti-racism, and how does that practice inform your faith?

Too Much and Too Little

Do not claim to be wiser than you are. – Romans 12:16b

“I always have the feeling I’ve said more than I intended to and less than they wanted me to. Too much and too little,” I tell my co-pastor.

I’ve just finished meeting with a congregant who has theological questions. On one hand, this is my favorite kind of appointment. A chance to dig in deep to the things that really matter.

And on the other, it’s so hard!

When people come to their pastors asking important questions like, “What does it mean to pray?” Or, “Where do we go when we die?” Or, “Why do bad things happen to good people?” They want answers.

And I have very few to give.

I have some knowledge of scripture, woefully incomplete. Some church history, even less so. And my own limited experience. None of this adds up to an answer. Or rather it adds up to lots of answers. The many ways others have understood these complex questions. And the one peculiar way I do.

Too much and too little.

And I feel the anxiety in the person across from me. Who would like something simpler and more concrete. I feel it, because I know it. That anxiety. That desire to know more than I do.

And it is a great teacher.

I don’t mean to sound wiser than I am. I never think about this in the moment.

But in hindsight, a sense of confusion and a longing to understand are the best tools I could offer for the spiritual journey. And the only ones I have to give.


As the heavens are higher than the earth, so you are to me, Mysterious One.